Betting Preview: Cincinnati Reds @ Pittsburgh Pirates – August 7, 2025
- Moneyline: Reds +144 (Underdogs)
- Implied Win Probability: 40.9%
- Model Win Probability: 45.3%
- Expected Value (EV): +33.5%
Overview
The Reds enter tonight’s matchup in Pittsburgh as moderately priced underdogs, but the market may be undervaluing their chances.
At +144, the implied win probability is just 40.9%, while model projections give Cincinnati a healthier 45.3% chance to win, creating
a substantial +33.5% Expected Value (EV).
While the Pirates have the more hyped starter in Paul Skenes, underlying game dynamics—especially Pittsburgh’s troubling run support
when he pitches—suggest this matchup is closer than odds indicate.
Starting Pitching Matchup
Brady Singer gets the ball for Cincinnati, continuing his solid if unspectacular 2025 campaign. The right-hander owns
a mid-4s ERA but has leaned heavily on his sinker/slider combo to induce groundballs and work out of jams. Singer’s volatility is
baked into the Reds’ pricing, but he’s shown the ability to limit damage when his command is on, and his experience navigating NL
Central lineups could play up in this spot.
For the Pirates, rookie sensation Paul Skenes continues to deliver electric results. Armed with an upper-90s fastball
and a wipeout slider, Skenes has carved through hitters with a strikeout rate well above 30% and an ERA in the low 3s. The issue? He
never gets any run support. Despite consistently putting his team in position to win, the Pirates have struggled mightily to score
when Skenes starts—averaging just 2.4 runs per game during his outings, one of the lowest support rates in baseball. Several of his
losses or no-decisions have come in quality starts where the offense simply failed to show up. That dynamic, combined with a bullpen
that’s been shaky in tight games, has turned dominant pitching into frustratingly neutral outcomes.
Team Form & Context
Cincinnati Reds
Cincinnati has been hovering around .500 recently, with streaky offense and a bullpen that’s outperformed expectations in late
innings. The team is 5–5 over its last 10 but has shown resilience in tight contests and road spots. The top of the lineup has been
working deep counts, and their ability to grind against high-strikeout arms may be key in chasing Skenes early.
Pittsburgh Pirates
The Pirates have struggled to capitalize on strong pitching performances. Despite the emergence of Skenes, they’ve dropped several of
his starts due to a combination of stagnant offense and mid-relief collapses. Pittsburgh is just 3–5 in games Skenes has started,
despite his personal ERA sitting near elite levels. The offense, especially in the bottom third of the order, continues to underwhelm
in high-leverage moments.
Offensive Splits & Matchup Edge
Reds vs RHP (Road):
Cincinnati hits .243 with a .719 OPS on the road against right-handers. Their 9.0% walk rate helps them stay competitive in at-bats,
especially against high-velocity arms like Skenes.
Pirates vs RHP (Home):
Pittsburgh hits just .231 at home vs righties, with a weak .675 OPS. They rank near the bottom of the league in slugging percentage
in these spots and struggle to string together rallies, often going long stretches without run production.
While Skenes is the most dominant pitcher in this game, he can’t bat for Pittsburgh—and the Reds’ offense has a clear edge in
matchup-adjusted production, especially if they can force the Pirates to the bullpen before the 7th inning.
Betting Angle & Value Summary
The market continues to price Skenes as if he’s guaranteed to win—and he may be the best young arm in the league—but the Pirates’
inability to score runs behind him is a massive issue. When you add in Cincinnati’s edge in offensive consistency and bullpen
execution, the +144 moneyline becomes a value-rich play. The model’s 45.3% win probability compared to the market’s 40.9% creates a
sharp EV of +33.5%, making the Reds a highly playable underdog.
Pick: Reds ML +144
Rationale: A value-driven underdog backed by model edge and contextual insight. Skenes is dominant, but Pittsburgh’s
lack of run support neutralizes that edge—and Cincinnati is well positioned to steal one on the road.



